How to Choose a Training Video Vendor: A Ten-Point Evaluation Sheet

How to choose a training video vendor: send every supplier the same brief, score each on the same ten criteria with weights fixed first, test a sample in your LMS and ask for every project file at handover.

Training video vendor stageWhat you doWhat it leaves behind
BriefWrite one brief and send it with the evaluation sheet to three to five suppliersThe same written brief for every supplier
WeightsFix the weights by risk before any proposal arrivesWeights on record
Scope sheetPut every quote on one sheet: module count, running length, languages, review rounds, accessibility, LMS testing, handover files and update windowQuotes that compare like for like
ScoringScore each criterion from zero to three using the evidence column only, with two people scoring independentlyTwo sets of scores to reconcile
SampleAsk the top two suppliers for a short sample built from one of your own SOPs, on agreed termsA sample from your own material
LMS test and reviewTest the sample in your LMS, run one review round and watch how corrections are handledA test result and a review log
RefereesPhone two referees who commissioned a comparable moduleReferee notes
DecisionDecide against the weighted scores, and pause the shortlist on red flags such as no named accuracy reviewer or no LMS trialA decision tied to the weights

To choose a training video vendor, send every shortlisted supplier the same written brief, score each on the same ten criteria, and fix the weights before any proposal arrives. The criteria cover content fit, source handling, review, AI use, languages, accessibility, LMS delivery, files, updates and scope.

Last reviewed: 13 November 2026

Vendor evaluation sheet: a single table scoring every supplier on each criterion, with the evidence behind each score.

What Ten Criteria Should You Score a Training Video Vendor On?

Put the sheet in your RFP. Each row needs an answer from the supplier plus a piece of evidence you can inspect, not a claim.

#CriterionAsk the vendorEvidence to accept
1Content fitWhich modules like ours have you made, and why does the format suit our audience?Two similar samples with learner and objective stated
2Source handlingHow does an SOP, policy or product sheet become a script, and who writes it?A script extract mapped to its source sections
3ReviewWho checks accuracy, how many rounds are in scope, who approves?Named reviewer roles, sample review log
4AI useWhere is AI used, and what does a person check before release?Written list of AI steps, voice and likeness consent terms
5LanguagesWho writes, records and verifies each language version?Named native reviewer per language, regional variants stated
6AccessibilityWhat arrives for captions, transcripts and audio description?Deliverables list per module
7LMS deliveryWhich package format (SCORM, xAPI or cmi5) is exported, and is it tested on our platform?Acceptance test plan, sample report
8Files and rightsWhich project files, scripts, captions and licences are handed over?Handover list, licence terms for voices, music, footage
9UpdatesHow does a policy change become a revised module?Written update process naming an owner
10Scope and confidentialityWhat is excluded, and where are confidential documents stored and who can open them?Scope sheet, data-handling note

Accessibility needs its own row because captions alone don't establish conformance: WCAG 2.2 success criterion 1.2.5 separately asks for audio description of prerecorded video at Level AA (W3C). LMS delivery earns a row because platforms interpret SCORM slightly differently, and the hard part is content that's both conformant and broadly compatible (SCORM.com).

How Do You Weight Criteria and Compare Quotes Fairly?

Fix the weights first, so scoring can't drift towards a studio you already favour. Public buyers work this way: US federal acquisition rules require evaluation factors and their relative importance to be stated clearly in the solicitation (Acquisition.gov). Private buyers can borrow that discipline.

Weight by risk. Regulated or safety content deserves the heaviest shares on review, source handling and LMS delivery; a multilingual rollout raises languages. Score each criterion from 0 to 3 using the evidence column only, with two people scoring independently before comparing notes, and agree a tie-breaker in advance.

Then put every quote on one scope sheet: module count, running length, languages, review rounds, accessibility deliverables, LMS testing, handover files and update window. A line an agency omits has not been priced, so request it rather than assuming it's included. Our guide to corporate training video costs in India explains each cost driver with a hypothetical comparison.

How Do You Run the Evaluation From Brief to Decision?

Run the evaluation as one sequence. Write the brief and send it with the sheet to three to five suppliers. Ask the top two for a short sample built from one of your own SOPs, on agreed terms. Test that sample in your LMS, run one review round and watch how corrections are handled. Phone two referees who commissioned a comparable module, then decide against the weighted scores. Comparing a tool with a studio first? See AI avatar tools vs a managed studio and AI vs traditional production.

Which Production Red Flags Should Pause a Shortlist?

A red flag is any answer that shifts risk onto you after signature. Pause the shortlist for these:

  • A fixed delivery date quoted before anyone has seen your source material.
  • Nobody named to check accuracy, or no sign-off before release.
  • A conformance claim resting on captions alone.
  • No trial run in your LMS before final delivery.
  • Scripts, caption files or project files missing from the handover.
  • Vague answers about AI use, or no consent terms for synthetic voices and likenesses.

Where Does Probbit Fit in a Vendor Evaluation?

Probbit is a corporate training video studio and can be one of the suppliers you score. Send us the same brief and sheet. We work with human writing, review and sign-off, agree the LMS package format and acceptance test before committing to delivery, and confirm languages, revision ownership and file handover in the project scope. Timing depends on approved source material, scope, languages and review rounds. To test the sheet on a real module, schedule a call.

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

What should a training video vendor brief contain?

State the audience and the task they must perform, the learning objective, the source documents and their owner, module count and running length, languages, LMS and package format, accessibility needs, named approvers, expected change frequency and a decision date. Suppliers can only quote like for like against a brief this specific.

How do you compare quotes from training video vendors fairly?

Ask each supplier to price one identical scope sheet listing every deliverable. Compare covered lines first and totals last. Treat any missing line as unpriced and request it in writing before scoring commercial fit. Quotes built on different assumptions, such as the number of review rounds, can't be compared.

What should you ask a training video vendor about review?

Ask who verifies accuracy against your source, how many review rounds the scope includes, who signs off before release and how corrections are logged. For safety or legal content, name your own approver, such as the site safety officer or counsel. Our AI training video accuracy checklist shows what a human reviewer should check.

What files should you request from a training video vendor?

Request final videos in the agreed aspect ratios, editable project files, the final script mapped to your source, caption and transcript files, every language version, the LMS package with its test report, and licence terms for voices, music and footage.

What are the red flags when choosing a training video vendor?

The most serious are a fixed delivery date before the supplier has read your source material, no named accuracy reviewer and no LMS trial. Weigh vague answers about AI use and missing consent terms next, then samples unrelated to your format.

Bring this to a call.

Thirty minutes on your curriculum and a straight answer on what to film first. Priced per module, scoped on the call.